Reporting a Claim

Claim form

Direct Claim Reports Available

At A.T. Matthews and Dier, we're available to handle your claim reports by phone at 315-782-2020. You also may report your claim directly to your insurance company. 

Phone Numbers for Carrier Claims

If you want to call your carrier directly to file a claim, here are the phone numbers for each company represented.

A-Central
1-866-222-2242

American Modern Home
1-866-267-7678 • Fax: 1-513-947-4000

Central Cooperative Insurance Company
1-800-621-9875

Classic Collectors Ins. Prog
1-800-348-4269 • Fax: 1-869-298-2527

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company
1-800-724-9876 • Fax: 1-607-844-3526

Erie Insurance Group
1-888-822-3743 • Glass Claim: 1-800-552-3743

Erie (Rochester)
1-800-333-0823 x 6500

Erie & Niagara Insurance Company
1-800-234-9876 • Fax: 1-716-632-9621

Foremost
1-800-527-3907

GMAC
1-800-468-3466 • Fax: 1-336-726-2300
Status: 1-888-233-4575

General Casualty
1-860-408-3268

Hagerty
1-800-747-5348

Harleysville Insurance Company
1-800-892-8877 • Fax: 1-800-441-4118

Infinity
1-800-782-1020

Kemper National Insurance Group
1-888-252-2799 • Fax: 1-877-329-5367

Lo Vullo Asso
1-800-876-3065 • Fax: 1-716-856-8057

Merchant Insurance Group
1-800-952-5246 • Safelite Glass: 1-877-446-0431
Fax: 1-800-235-6304

Midstate Mutual Insurance
Fax Accord: 252-4312

National Grange Mutual Insurance Company
1-877-425-2467 • Fax: 1-877-282-3844
Glass Claim: 1-800-887-5944

New York Central Mutual Insurance
1-800-355-1717 • Fax: 1-607-965-2136
Towing/Glass: 1-888-234-6926
Flood: 1-800-787-6677 • Fax: 1-301-279-0364

Progressive
1-800-274-4499
Local: 785-8124 OR 788-3983

Security Mutual Insurance Company
1-800-822-1232
Fax: 1-607-257-5230 OR 1-607-266-0635

Travelers Insurance Group
1-800-252-4633
Commercial & WC: 1-800-832-7839
at 636 Coffeen Street 
or call 315-782-2020
to get full insurance coverage
Open from 8:30 am to 5:00 pm 
Monday through Friday

Share by: